Vergleich

Humble Planning vs Planday

Flexible planning vs rigid shift management

Planday besuchen

Planday is a workforce management platform designed for shift-based field teams (hospitality, retail, healthcare). It focuses on shift scheduling, time tracking and payroll integration. It's a direct competitor for hourly scheduling.

Preise

Humble Planning

Ab 25 EUR/Monat (alles inklusive, 10 Benutzer).

Planday

Hosting

Humble Planning

Selbst gehostet oder Cloud in Frankreich (ISO 27001, HDS)

Planday

Zielmarkt

Humble Planning

KMU bis Mittelstand, branchenübergreifend, Projekt- und Außenteams

Planday

Funktion

Humble Planning
Planday
Self-hosting
Data in France
Transparent pricing
Built-in AI (30+ MCP tools)
Multiple views (5 modes)
Shift only
Project management
Budget & ROI
Audit trail
PDF planning export
Payroll integration
Digital time clock
White-label

Im Detail

Versatility vs shift specialization

Humble Planning manages project, resource and people planning with 5 different views. Planday is exclusively designed for shifts (fixed time slots). If your needs go beyond simple team rotation, Humble Planning offers much greater flexibility.

Pricing transparency

Humble Planning publicly displays its pricing: starting at EUR40/month, all included. Planday doesn't publish its prices and requires a minimum of 5 users. No surprises or hidden costs with Humble Planning.

Performance and reliability

Planday is regularly criticized for performance issues (slowdowns, freezes) and limited reporting features. Humble Planning is built on a modern stack (Next.js + Bun + PostgreSQL) with real-time via Socket.io.

What Planday does well

Planday excels in shift management with integrated digital time clock, direct payroll software integration, and absence/leave management. For restaurants and hotels with shift-based teams, it's a very well-suited tool.

Humble Planning ist das Richtige für Sie, wenn...

  • You manage projects, not just shifts
  • You need multiple views (users, projects, places, resources)
  • You want clear and public pricing
  • You want built-in AI to automate planning
  • Performance and real-time matter to you

Bereit, Humble Planning zu testen?

Entdecken Sie unsere transparenten Preise oder kontaktieren Sie uns für eine Vorführung.